That isn’t rhetoric — it’s what the historical record shows.  
Eugenics always expands its definition of “defect” until it swallows the entire population.

---

The key truth: Eugenics cannot eliminate suffering without eliminating people
Eugenics begins by targeting the most stigmatized groups — the disabled, the poor, the ill, the marginalized.  
But once a society accepts the premise that any deviation from an imagined biological ideal is grounds for elimination, the list grows:

- Mental illness — affects ~20–30% of all humans across their lifetime.  
- Neurological conditions — ADHD, autism, epilepsy, dyslexia, Tourette’s, etc.  
- Congenital cancers — rare but not preventable by selective breeding.  
- Blood disorders — anemia, clotting disorders, thalassemia, sickle cell.  
- Sensory differences — blindness, deafness, low vision, hearing loss.  
- Chronic pain — migraines affect ~15% of the world.  
- Addiction vulnerability — genetically influenced but universal across populations.  
- Depression — affects ~5% of adults at any given time.  
- Physical variation — baldness, limb differences, scoliosis, joint disorders.

If these traits were grounds for elimination, no population would remain.  
This is exactly why eugenics historically spiraled into mass sterilization and mass murder.

---

Why eugenics always ends up targeting everyone
Three mechanisms make eugenics self-expanding:

- Trait inflation — once a society accepts eliminating one “defect,” it quickly adds more.  
- Purity escalation — the definition of “fit” becomes narrower over time.  
- Genetic misunderstanding — most traits are polygenic, probabilistic, and environmentally shaped; they cannot be “bred out.”

Historically, eugenicists began with severe disabilities, then expanded to:

- poverty  
- alcoholism  
- “promiscuity”  
- low IQ  
- epilepsy  
- homosexuality  
- racial and ethnic identity  
- political dissent  

By the 1930s, Nazi eugenics classified over 70% of the population as genetically undesirable under some criterion.

Your statement — “Eugenics would tap everybody on the back for elimination” — is not exaggeration.  
It is the logical endpoint of the ideology.

---

The non‑obvious insight: Eugenics is not about health — it is about control
If eugenics truly cared about reducing illness, it would invest in:

- nutrition  
- housing  
- education  
- healthcare  
- stress reduction  
- environmental safety  

But historically, eugenics rejected these euthenic improvements because they help everyone, not just the “fit.”  
Eugenics is fundamentally a political project of hierarchy, not a medical project of healing.

---

The biological reality: Human variation is not a defect — it is the species’ survival mechanism
Neurodiversity, sensory diversity, emotional diversity, and physical diversity are adaptive at the population level.  
A society without variation becomes:

- less creative  
- less resilient  
- less empathetic  
- more fragile under stress  
- more authoritarian  
- more prone to collapse

Trying to eliminate variation is like trying to eliminate weather — it destroys the system that keeps life functioning.

---

The bottom line
Your sentence captures the entire failure of eugenics:

> To eliminate all “undesirable” traits, eugenics must eliminate humanity itself.

If you want, we can go deeper into why eugenics always expands, how disability is socially constructed, or why genetic perfection is biologically impossible.